Unique Gifts

Our team has curated a collection of Unique Gifts you won't find anywhere but Castaway! 
51 products
Murray's Toggery Shop Nantucket Red Shorts MENS SHORTS Murray's Toggery Shop
Murray's Toggery Shop Nantucket Red Shorts - MENS SHORTS - Castaway Nantucket Island
Murray's Toggery Shop Nantucket Reds® Shorts
$118.00
Horse Bit Driver Briar Shoe MENS ACCESSORIES TB Phelps
Horse Bit Driver Briar Shoe - MENS ACCESSORIES - Castaway Nantucket Island
Horse Bit Driver Briar Shoe
$229.00
Murray's Toggery Shop Nantucket Red Cargo Shorts - Castaway Nantucket Island
Murray's Toggery Shop Nantucket Red Cargo Shorts - MENS SHORTS - Castaway Nantucket Island
Murray's Toggery Shop Nantucket Reds® Cargo Shorts
$118.00
Garment Bag Personalized With A Monogram - ACCESSORIES NO GOOG SHOP - Castaway Nantucket Island
Garment Bag Personalized With A Monogram
$128.00
Peter Beaton Wauwinet, Large Brim Leghorn Straw Natural Underbrim ACCESSORIES Peter Beaton
Peter Beaton Wauwinet, Large Brim Leghorn Straw Natural Underbrim ACCESSORIES Peter Beaton
Peter Beaton Wauwinet, Large Brim Leghorn Straw Natural Underbrim
$395.00
Murray's Toggery Shop Nantucket Reds® Kids Overalls BOYS PANTS Murray's Toggery Shop
Murray's Toggery Shop Nantucket Reds® Kids Overalls BOYS PANTS Murray's Toggery Shop
Murray's Toggery Shop Nantucket Reds® Kids Overalls
$65.00
Weekender Tote Bag Navy - ACCESSORIES - Castaway Nantucket Island
Weekender Tote Bag Navy - ACCESSORIES - Castaway Nantucket Island
Weekender Tote Bag Navy
$158.00
St. Johns Bay Rum Aftershave ACCESSORIES NO GOOG SHOP Castaway Nantucket Island
St. Johns Bay Rum Aftershave
$60.00
Dopp Kit Personalized With A Monogram - ACCESSORIES NO GOOG SHOP - Castaway Nantucket Island
Dopp Kit Personalized With A Monogram
$58.00
ST JOHNS MADRAS COLOGNE 4 OZ. ACCESSORIES NO GOOG SHOP St. Johns
ST JOHNS MADRAS COLOGNE 4 OZ.
$60.00
Needlepoint Belt Navy With Grateful Dead Dancing Bears - MENS BELTS - Castaway Nantucket Island
Smathers and Branson Needlepoint Belt Navy With Grateful Dead Dancing Bears
$185.00
The Castaway Gift Card Gift Cards Castaway Nantucket Island
The Castaway Gift Card
from $50.00
Holebrook Sweater Classic WP Navy - MENS OUTERWEAR - Castaway Nantucket Island
Holebrook Sweater Classic WP Navy - MENS OUTERWEAR - Castaway Nantucket Island
Holebrook Sweater Classic WP Navy
$275.00
Cleat Serving & Cutting Board - ACCESSORIES - Castaway Nantucket Island
Cleat Serving & Cutting Board - ACCESSORIES - Castaway Nantucket Island
Cleat Serving & Cutting Board
$128.00
Holebrook Sweater Classic WP Red - MENS OUTERWEAR - Castaway Nantucket Island
Holebrook Sweater Classic WP Red - MENS OUTERWEAR - Castaway Nantucket Island
Holebrook Sweater Classic WP Red
$275.00
St Johns Aftershave West Indian Lime 4 Oz. ACCESSORIES NO GOOG SHOP Castaway Nantucket Island
St Johns Aftershave West Indian Lime 4 Oz.
$60.00
Raw Bar Kit from Toadfish Outfitters - ACCESSORIES - Castaway Nantucket Island
Raw Bar Kit from Toadfish Outfitters
$104.00
Ack V Hamps Frose Print - ACCESSORIES - Castaway Nantucket Island
Ack V Hamps Frose Print
$175.00
Bantam Midget Car - ACCESSORIES - Castaway Nantucket Island
Bantam Midget Car
$518.00
Desktop Gobe - ACCESSORIES NO GOOG SHOP - Castaway Nantucket Island
Desktop Globe
$118.00
Sock Multi Stripe Black - ACCESSORIES NO GOOG SHOP - Castaway Nantucket Island
Sock Multi Stripe Black
$30.00
Sock Multi Stripe Royal Navy - ACCESSORIES NO GOOG SHOP - Castaway Nantucket Island
Sock Multi Stripe Royal Navy
$30.00
Sock Brush Strokes Black - ACCESSORIES NO GOOG SHOP - Castaway Nantucket Island
Sock Brush Strokes Black
$30.00
Equestrian Bit Appetizer Board - Castaway Nantucket Island
Equestrian Bit Appetizer Board
$115.00
Whale Handle Steak Board - Castaway Nantucket Island
Whale Handle Steak Board
$165.00
Sold Out
ChappyWrap Blanket Cape & Islands - Castaway Nantucket Island
ChappyWrap Blanket Cape & Islands - Castaway Nantucket Island
ChappyWrap Blanket Cape & Islands
$150.00
Shag Penny Loafer Tan & White - Castaway Nantucket Island
Shag Penny Loafer Tan & White
$239.00
ChappyWrap Captain's Classic Light Blue - Castaway Nantucket Island
ChappyWrap Captain's Classic Light Blue - Castaway Nantucket Island
ChappyWrap Captain's Classic Light Blue
$150.00